Those who answered ‘yes’ were asked to indicate the

locat

Those who answered ‘yes’ were asked to indicate the

location of their pain, which was noted by DH on a diagram of the body included in the questionnaire. selleck chemicals llc The lower limb was divided into the following regions: hip, knee, ankle, foot, anterior upper leg, posterior upper leg, anterior lower leg, and posterior lower leg. A medical expert with local language skills performed monitoring visits throughout data collection to ensure questions were being translated correctly. Then, an observation walk was conducted with the village leader and village health worker. This involved walking through the village and surrounding farmlands, and listing the presence of factors that could contribute to lower limb pain. Villagers were included if they were over 15 years old. In each village, a minimum of 26 people were interviewed. If the household containing the 26th person had

further eligible people, these people were also interviewed. In order to detect a prevalence of lower limb pain of 20%, with 80% power, a p value of 0.05, and taking into account the effect of cluster sampling (design factor = 2), the required sample size was 492. Data were analysed by PD173074 in vitro calculating proportions for data not derived from simple random samples. In order to examine the pattern of lower limb musculoskeletal pain further, the group was divided by age (people aged 15 to 49 years vs those 50 years or older) and by gender. Point and 12-month prevalence were calculated for each of these subgroups. first The effect of cluster sampling was taken into account when calculating the confidence intervals. Odds ratios (95% CI) were calculated for the differences between gender and age. Information from the observation walks was grouped into common themes by the researchers, village leaders, and health workers. Factors that may contribute to the prevalence of lower limb musculoskeletal pain are reported descriptively. In total, 499 people aged 15 years or over were interviewed across 19 villages.

All people visited agreed to participate, and their characteristics are presented in Table 1. Of the participants 307 (62%) were female. The mean age of females was 43 years (SD 16) and of males was 42 years (SD 16). When stratified by decade, the most common age group was 30 to 39 years. The point prevalence of lower limb pain was 40% (95% CI 34 to 46). The point prevalence of knee pain was 25% (95% CI 20 to 30) which was significantly higher than pain at any other site in the lower limb. There was no significant difference between the other sites in point prevalence of pain. The twelve-month prevalence was only marginally higher at 48% (95% CI 42 to 54) for lower limb pain and similar at 29% (95% CI 23 to 35) for knee pain. The odds of females having current ankle pain were 1.9 (95% CI 1.0 to 3.5) times that of males (Table 2).

05) IFN-γ levels were significantly augmented in vaccinated grou

05). IFN-γ levels were significantly augmented in vaccinated groups in comparison to unvaccinated birds, in spleen and caecal tonsils ( Fig. 3) before challenge. IFN-γ expression

in caecal tonsils was significantly elevated in groups C and E at 1 dbi, and at 6 dpi in group E, in comparison with the other groups (p < 0.05). IL-10 was highly expressed in spleen samples of all vaccinated groups in comparison with group A at 1 dbi (p < 0.05). At 1 dpi, the expression of this cytokine in spleen decreased in all groups, except in group D. In caecal tonsils, IL-10 levels were higher in groups C and E before challenge, and a peak was seen at 6 dpi in group Ku-0059436 molecular weight E ( Fig. 3). The recruitment of CD8+ T cells in liver and caecal

tonsils, evaluated by immunohistochemistry, is displayed in Fig. 4. Before the challenge, at 1 dbi, all groups had low levels of CD8+ T cells in caecal tonsil. ERK inhibitor At 1 dpi, the influx of CD8+ T cells started to increase in all groups, including the unvaccinated group A. At 6 dpi, cell influx was significantly higher in groups A and C, and at 9 dpi, groups B and C showed the highest levels of CD8+ T cells (p < 0.05), in caecal tonsil samples however, groups D and E exhibited significantly lower levels of CD8+ T cells, similar to the unvaccinated group A. In liver samples, CD8+ T cells were present at 1 dbi, although, only groups B, C and E were significantly different from the control group A. After challenge, the cell influx in the liver was clearly increased in all groups, and the highest levels were seen in group A; values in group D were constant and had no significant increase during this period. At 6 dpi,

the amount of CD8+ T cells was not different between Methisazone vaccinated groups (p > 0.05). However, at 9 dpi, groups B and C showed higher numbers of CD8+ T cells than groups D and E in liver. Studies regarding the influence of live and killed vaccines on the immune responses of commercial chickens are important to clarify the specific mechanisms involved. Discussions about the use of Salmonella vaccines are always controversial; live vaccines are often questioned about reversion to virulence, whilst killed vaccines are described as weak stimulators of the CMI [18] and [38]. The present study, and others, demonstrates that bacterins stimulate the humoral response which is ineffective on its own, to control Salmonella infection [39]. However, KV can reduce Salmonella burden in poultry flocks when used with a biosecurity program [5] and [40]. Immune responses generated by invasive live vaccines should trigger similar processes as the pathogenic strains. The mutant SG invaded the host organism from the gut and colonized internal organs similarly to the wild strain [10]. Additionally vaccine strains with known genetic deletions (GMO) have reduced risks of reversion to virulence, in comparison with rough strains [41].

8), this was not statistically significant, even when vaccine gro

8), this was not statistically significant, even when vaccine groups were analysed together (p = 0.29), suggesting that any blood stage effect of vaccination was minimal. Asexual blood stage growth rates did not correlate significantly with time to parasitaemia (data not shown). However, the estimated number of infected hepatocytes generated during the liver stage of infection (derived from the PCR rate data) does correlate with the time to blood-film positive parasitaemia (Spearman’s p = 0.0004,

rho = −0.71, Fig. 8c). We conducted a prospective phase I/IIa dose-escalation and sporozoite challenge trial in healthy malaria-naïve human volunteers administered PLX4032 mw the novel malaria vaccines FP9-PP and MVA-PP. Vaccinations in the prime-boost groups were given one month apart and volunteers underwent challenge three weeks after the last vaccination. The vaccines encode a ‘polyprotein’

construct (‘L3SEPTL’) consisting of six pre-erythrocytic malaria antigens (from N to C terminus): LSA3, STARP, Exp1, Pfs16, TRAP and LSA1. Although the aim of immunisation was to stimulate check details a pre-erythrocytic cellular response, expression during the blood stage of the malaria parasite lifecycle has also been reported for STARP [13], Exp1 [14] and for a LSA3 homologue [12] and [24]. Pfs16 is also expressed at sexual stages [25]. The expressed protein is 3240 amino acids long and has been shown to induce T cell responses to peptide pools from each of the six antigens in mice [4]. To our knowledge this is the largest foreign insert in a viral vectored vaccine tested in a clinical trial. The viral vectors employed here have been used extensively in human vaccination [7], [26] and [27]. Previous vaccine studies using these Linifanib (ABT-869) vectors in human prime-boost regimes with much smaller inserts have demonstrated

the ability to induce strong T-cell responses measured by the ex vivo IFNγ-ELISPOT and induce sterile protection on malaria challenge in some volunteers [7]. The approach explored in this study was to attempt to broaden the vaccine-induced immune response to cover multiple malarial antigens and provide strong pre-erythrocytic and perhaps some blood-stage immunity. The potential advantages of a broader immune response should be to: (1) reduce the risk of immune escape; (2) improve potential protective efficacy by increasing the number of antigens and epitopes targeted by protective T cells; (3) limit inter-individual variation in vaccine immunogenicity related to HLA-restriction and lack of T cell epitopes in a single antigen insert; and (4) provide a more cost-effective solution than vaccinating with mixtures of multiple single-antigen vaccines. Both vaccines were found to be safe and well tolerated. Higher doses of the vaccines did not appear to increase the frequency or severity of local AEs. Increasing doses of MVA-PP were associated with a greater frequency of systemic AEs, though generally of mild severity.

Intake of acetaminophen like drugs and certain chemicals may also

Intake of acetaminophen like drugs and certain chemicals may also lead to hepatocellular carcinoma. N-nitrosodiethylamine (NDEA) is a potent carcinogenic dialkyl nitrosoamine present in tobacco smoke, water, cheddar cheese, cured and fried meals and in a number of alcoholic beverages. It is a hepatocarcinogen producing reproducible HCC after repeated administration. 1 The formation of reactive

oxygen species (ROS) during the metabolism of NDEA may be one of the key factors in the etiology of cancer. 2 HCC is associated with over expression of vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) which are produced by hepatocytes in the periportal area of liver tissue. 3 In addition to the animal experimental models of cancer, human cancer cell lines have been widely used to study the antiproliferative effect. Selleckchem JAK inhibitor Numerous components of plants, collectively termed “phytochemicals” have been reported to possess substantial chemopreventive properties. Development of nontoxic and biologically safe anticarcinogenic agent has been highlighted as a promising way to treat carcinogenesis.4 Several herbal drugs like Acacia nilotica, Achyranthes aspera, Scutia myrtina, etc have been evaluated for its potential as liver protectant against NDEA

induced hepatotoxicity in rats. 1, 5 and 6 Woodfordia fruticosa (Lythraceae) is a traditional medicinal plant and its dried flowers are used as tonic in disorders Quisinostat manufacturer of mucous membrane, hemorrhoids and in derangement of liver. 7 Phenolics, particularly hydrolyzable tannins and flavonoids were identified as major components of W. fruticosa flowers. In view of these the present work was undertaken to evaluate the protective effect of W. fruticosa against NDEA induced hepatocellular carcinoma in experimental rats and in human hepatoma PLC/PRF/5 cell lines. NDEA, Silymarin, anti-mouse IgG horseradish peroxidase,

streptavidin horseradish peroxidase conjugate, diaminobenzidine, Fetal bovine serum (FBS) and N-2-hydroxyethylpiperazine-N-2-ethane-sulphonic Ketanserin acid (HEPES) were purchased from Sigma Chemical Co., St. Louis, MO, USA. VEGF antibody from Santa Cruz Biotechnology, Santa Cruz, CA, USA. Alpha feto-protein (AFP) assay kit was purchased from Creative diagnostics, USA. Assay kits for serum alkaline phosphatase (ALP), lactate dehydrogenase (LDH) and bilirubin were purchased from Agappe Diagnostics, India. 5-flourouracil (5-FU) was purchased from Biochem Pharmaceutical Industries, Mumbai, India. RPMI Medium and antibiotic-antimycotic were purchased from Gibco, Grand Island, N.Y, USA. Cell Proliferation Assay kit [3-(4,5-dimethylthiazol-2-yl)-2,5diphenyltetrazoliumbromide (MTT)] was purchased from HiMedia, India. Dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) was obtained from Merck, Mumbai, India. All other chemicals were of analytical grade.

The motivation for using these types of “placebos” is to benefit

The motivation for using these types of “placebos” is to benefit participants in the control arm and avoid giving an injection with an inert substance. However, this motivation undescores the importance of ensuring that the comparator vaccine(s) are proven to be beneficial in the study population. Furthermore, it is important to recognize that trials using such “placebos” may provide a less perfect control if the effects of the comparator vaccine(s) confound the evaluation of the risk-benefit profile of the experimental vaccine.

For this reason, use of such “placebos” may also be less acceptable to regulators or public health authorities and potentially delay approval or adoption GABA inhibition of a new vaccine. Applying the above ethical framework requires that investigators, sponsors, local communities, RECs, drug/vaccine regulators, public health authorities, policy-makers, and other relevant parties make complex normative and empirical judgments. All of these stakeholders therefore have an obligation to ensure that decisions about vaccine trial design, and especially the use of placebo controls when an efficacious vaccine exists, are made based on the best available evidence Vorinostat and under consideration of all relevant reasons. All vaccine trials should undergo REC review prior to before enrolling

participants. Investigators and sponsors are responsible for submitting a research protocol that gives a clear ethical justification

for the proposed trial design in line with the above considerations and presents relevant empirical evidence in a balanced and comprehensible way. The protocol should explain clearly both the scientific justification for and the social value of using a placebo-controlled design and discuss the relative merits of alternative trial designs. The justification for not using an existing vaccine as a comparator should include discussion of the acceptability, availability, and accessibility of the existing vaccine for the prospective trial population. It must be clear that the study question cannot be answered in an active-controlled trial in the target population. Furthermore, the protocol should provide evidence to support all empirical claims. This includes relevant evidence from previous clinical and non-clinical studies; evidence from consultation with experts (e.g. to support claims about the local safety and efficacy of an existing vaccine); evidence from consultation with local stakeholders (e.g. to show that the study infrastructure is appropriate); and evidence from formative surveys or interviews (e.g. to demonstrate local acceptability of the vaccine if found effective).

A modeling exercise comparing the impact of different vaccination

A modeling exercise comparing the impact of different vaccination strategies at the population level is currently being carried out for Germany and will inform STIKO decision-making in addition to other data such as the results derived from the present survey. We express our sincere thanks to the 15 pediatricians that pretested the questionnaire, all participating physicians and the German Professional Association for Pediatricians (BVKJ) for their support of the survey. Furthermore, we thank all colleagues in the Immunization Unit at the Robert Koch Institute for help with the survey logistics, especially Sarah Wetzel, ERK inhibitors Gabi Metzner-Zülsdorf, Kerstin Dehmel and Willi Koch, and Kristin

Tolksdorf for her statistical advice. The study was funded by the Robert Koch Institute. Conflict of interest None of the authors report potential conflicts of interest. “
“Influenza is an important cause of morbidity and mortality globally, resulting in an estimated

3–5 million cases of severe influenza illness and 250,000–500,000 annual deaths worldwide [1]. The annual attack rate with influenza viruses is 5–10% in adults and 20–30% in children [2]. Groups at particular GW-572016 purchase risk of severe influenza infections include pregnant women, children aged <5 years, the elderly (≥65 years), and individuals with underlying non-communicable health conditions such as heart disease, asthma and diabetes. Most influenza deaths occur in adults over 65 years of age. Vaccination is currently the most effective means of preventing influenza infection. Currently licensed influenza vaccines are safe and efficacious because and prevent significant annual morbidity and mortality [2]. Recommended target populations for influenza vaccination programs include pregnant women, children aged 6–59 months, the elderly,

individuals with specific chronic non-communicable diseases, and health-care workers [2]. In 2003, a World Health Assembly (WHA) resolution set a target calling for an increase in influenza vaccine coverage rates (VCR) for all people at high risk and at least 50% of the elderly by 2006, and 75% by 2010 [3]. Since then, the Council of the European Union has recommended that member states achieve VCR of 75% in the elderly and other risk groups and improve the vaccination coverage in health care workers by the 2014–2015 influenza season [4]. With clear national and supranational recommendations for vaccination, countries would be expected to achieve the recommended 75% vaccination coverage target. Yet influenza vaccination coverage remains below recommended levels in many countries. In Europe, influenza vaccination is recommended for about 36% of the population or approximately 180 million persons. Yet only about 80 million persons (44% of the population for whom vaccination is recommended) are estimated to receive vaccine annually [5]. In the US, influenza vaccination coverage in all age groups combined was 41.8% in 2011–2012 [6].

Ten days after the last DC transfer, each group of 10 mice was ch

Ten days after the last DC transfer, each group of 10 mice was challenged with 500 T. spiralis ML. All mice were sacrificed 45 days after www.selleckchem.com/products/SB-431542.html larval challenge, and the muscle larvae were collected as described previously. The larval reduction in the group of mice that were transferred with rTs-Hsp70-stimulated DCs compared to that of the group that was transferred with PBS-incubated DCs was calculated. Reductions in larval burden in immunized mice were calculated according to the following formula: % larvae reduction=1−mean number of larvae per gram muscle in immunized micemean number of larvae per gram muscle in control mice×100%

The data are shown as the mean ± the standard error (S.E.). All experiments were performed in triplicate. Statistical analyses were performed using GraphPad Prism 6 (GraphPad InStatt Software, USA). p < 0.05 was considered as statistically significant. FACS analysis revealed that both rTs-Hsp70 and LPS up-regulated the expressions SCH 900776 in vivo of MHC II, CD40, CD80 and CD86 on the DCs, but there was no effect on the expression of CD11c ( Fig. 1A). Neither the His-tagged control protein rTs-PmyN nor PBS

affected the expressions of these markers. To further determine whether rTs-Hsp70 stimulated the maturation of the DCs, the typical cytokines produced by mature DCs were measured. DC-secreted IL-1β, IL-6, IL-12p70, and TNF-α were significantly elevated upon rTs-Hsp70 stimulation compared to the levels secreted by the DCs that were incubated with PBS or the non-relevant recombinant protein control (rTs-Pmy-N) ( Fig. 1B). The addition of polymyxin B inhibited the stimulation by LPS but not that of rTs-Hsp70. This finding excludes the effect of possible endotoxin contamination

in the recombinant Ts-Hsp70. After incubation with 10 μg/ml of rTs-Hsp70 for 48 h, the DCs were pretreated with mitomycin C and then co-cultivated for 48 h with CD4+ T cells that had been isolated from the spleens of T. spiralis-infected. The proliferation of the T cells that was induced Thymidine kinase by the activated DCs was investigated using MTS kits. The results revealed that the proliferation of the CD4+ T cells was significantly induced by the rTs-Hsp70-activated DCs compared to PBS- and the non-relevant protein-(rTs-Pmy) incubated DCs ( Fig. 2A). The levels of IFN-γ, IL-2, IL-4, and IL-6 secreted by the CD4+ T cells were measured following co-incubated with the DCs (Fig. 2B). The production of both Th1 (IFN-γ and IL-2) and Th2 cytokines (IL-4 and IL-6) were highly elevated in the cells that were incubated with rTs-Hsp70-activated DCs compared to the levels from cells that were incubated with the PBS- and non-relevant protein (Ts-Pmy-N)-incubated DCs.

These symptoms following vaccination were grouped into 3 time per

These symptoms following vaccination were grouped into 3 time periods: immediate reactions (i.e. within 30 min), short term reactions (within 7 days post-vaccination) and longer term reactions (from

8 through 30 days post-vaccination) (Table 1). After each dose, no immediate reactions were observed. After any dose fewer children reported any symptoms within 7 days compared to the 3-week period from 8 to 30 days past vaccination. Fewer children reported any symptoms after dose 2 and dose 3, compared with dose 1. Irritability and fever were the 2 most frequently reported symptoms following administration any dose of Rotarix™ or Rotavin-M1 but none of the differences between groups reached significance. Of special notes, within 7 days after receiving the first dose, 3 children from group BKM120 chemical structure 3L (7.5%), 3 from group 2H (7.5%), 1 from group 3H (2.5%) and 1 from group Rotarix™ (2.5%) exhibited mild diarrhea. Given the small numbers, this difference was not statistically significant and suggested that the vaccine virus had been adequately attenuated (Table 1). Rotavirus antigen was isolated in fecal specimens

from 1 case in each of the groups Rotarix™, 3H and 2H during this period. From days 8–30, diarrhea episodes were reported only in groups Rotarix™ and 3H (1 and Gemcitabine 4 cases, respectively), of which only one case in group 3H was positive for rotavirus. While a few infants had mild diarrhea after administration of dose 2 or 3, only 1 case in group 3H (within 7 days after dose 2) and 1 case in group 3L (within 7 days after dose 3) were identified as rotavirus G1P [8]. Sequences of VP7 gene of these samples revealed that they were 100% homologous with the sequence of Rotavin-M1 or Rotarix™ (in respective groups). Of note, Rotarix™ and Rotavin-M1 share 93.6% homology in the 793 nucleotide sequence of VP7 gene and 94.7% homology in the 263 amino acid sequence of the encoded protein. Serum samples were analysed at NIHE and anonymized results were confirmed at CDC. Most infants (94.5%)

did not have detectable RV-IgA before vaccination and all children with one pre-vaccination serum and at least one post-vaccination serum samples were included in the analysis of immunogenicity. One of the 2 children who was seropositive to before vaccination seroconverted (group 3H, data not shown). One month after the 2nd dose of vaccine, the rate of seroconversion to Rotavin-M1 vaccine was 61% (95%CI (45%, 76%)) for group 2L (106.0 FFU) and 73% (95%CI (58%, 88%)) for group 2H (106.3 FFU) (Table 2). The IgA-GMT, ranging from 76 (group 2H) to 89 (group 2L), did not differ between these two groups. For groups receiving 3 doses of vaccines (groups 3L and 3H), anti-RV-IgA seroconversion rates at 1 month after 2 doses of vaccine were 51% (95%CI (36%, 67%)) for group 3L (106.0 FFU) and 61% (95%CI (45%, 77%)) for group 3H (106.3 FFU).

Parents’ employment status and education level, breastfeeding (ye

Parents’ employment status and education level, breastfeeding (yes/no), parental smoking, perceived family financial situation in childhood, and grandparents’ ethnocultural origin were considered as potential determinants.

BCG vaccination status was documented in the Québec BCG Vaccination Registry and classified in three categories: not vaccinated, vaccinated during the provincial program (in 1974), or vaccinated after the program (1975 onwards). Since < 1% of vaccinated subjects received the vaccine more than once, only the first-time vaccination was considered. Analyses were done on three different complete datasets: (1) subjects without missing values for the 11 variables documented in administrative databases; (2) subjects without missing values for the 9 variables from interviews; and (3) subjects without missing values on variables from both sources, as selected in the previous Selleck INCB024360 two steps. Among each complete signaling pathway set, separate logistic regression models were constructed by manual backward elimination

processes for vaccination in each period (during/after the provincial program), contrasting those vaccinated with those who were not. Odds ratios (ORs) and 95% confidence intervals (CI) were estimated. Then, multiple imputations by the Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) method (UCLA, n.d.) were performed, given the non-monotone missing pattern. After each complete set analysis, MCMC multiple imputations (5 imputed datasets for Stage 1 sample, and 20 for Stage 2 sample) were carried out, and ORs and 95% CI were estimated for the full dataset. Models were

built as follows. The variables documented in administrative databases were analyzed in the first complete set. The initial model included all variables with p-values < 0.25 from univariable models. At each step, the variable with the highest p-value was considered for elimination, but given the large sample size, even weak associations were highly significant. The variable was removed if the goodness-of-fit was unchanged or improved; it was kept if the goodness-of-fit decreased upon removing it based on the Akaïke Information Criterion (AIC) (Burnham and Anderson, 2002). The variables collected at interview were analyzed in the second complete set. The same criteria as before were used for initial selection medroxyprogesterone of variables. However, final models from the backward elimination process were based on statistical significance and included variables with a p-value < 0.05. Similar regression models were constructed using variables from both sources (administrative databases and interviews), as selected in previous steps. These analyses were conducted with the third complete set, using backward elimination as in the second set of analyses. Regression models involving data from interviews was adjusted for asthma occurrence (yes/no), in order to correct for the sampling fractions from the Stage 1 to Stage 2 sample (Collet et al., 1998).

Sometimes WHO representatives may also participate in the working

Sometimes WHO representatives may also participate in the working

groups. After assessing all available data, the committee will reach consensus and recommendations will be made. If consensus proves impossible, the matter will be sent to the MoH, to make the final decision. Agreed MS-275 in vivo recommendations are forwarded to the ultimate decision-makers within the MoH and then widely circulated via circulars and newsletters. It should be noted that to date the committee has always followed official WHO recommendations for vaccine use. Formal contact between the committee members and similar NITAGs in the Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) countries is facilitated through an annual inter-country selleck chemical meeting on communicable diseases that includes all the countries of the GCC. This comprises Bahrain, Kuwait, Oman, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, the United Arab

Emirates and Yemen. Half of the meeting each year is devoted to discussing issues concerning the Expanded Programme on Immunization (EPI), including the introduction of new vaccines and immunization issues. In 2007, it was recommended that GCC countries would have a common EPI schedule, a decision validated by all NITAGs in GCC countries and then approved by the relevant Ministers. As of 1 January 2008, the decision was implemented. The cost of vaccines, as well as that of the overall immunization program, is considered when the committee decides on its recommendations. Formal economic evaluations are made (cost-effectiveness, cost-benefit and cost-utility) and both affordability and sustainability are assessed. Subcommittees, with the assistance of health economic experts from within the MoH, assist in making these evaluations—for example, an economic evaluation of rotavirus vaccine disease burden was undertaken. They are currently assessing the human papillomavirus (HPV) disease burden from an economic

perspective. Additionally, assessments made regionally are taken into account, particularly when provided by WHO’s Eastern Mediterranean Regional Office (EMRO) or from other GCC countries, such as in the case of cost-effectiveness studies on HPV. Recommendations are circulated to all members to receive their comments, after which they are sent found to decision-makers for final approval. The Government is obliged to implement committee recommendations. The Ministry of Finance and other government departments play no part in decision-making. A good example of how decisions are made can be found in the case of the introduction of PCV-7 into the EPI schedule in Oman. At the time, there was very strong demand from the vaccine committee members and paediatricians to introduce the vaccine. As a result, the committee recommended forming a task force to study the disease burden and the vaccine’s cost-effectiveness.